Wednesday, May 20, 2015

Composition Reconsidered

Composition Reconsidered
The last two chapters plus the conclusion of Shipka’s book, Toward a Composition Made Whole, do a great job of expounding her pedagogical approaches.  She details the importance of stepping away from convention and how doing so engages students in a more profound way.  They are forced to analyze the choices that they make.  They are encouraged to produce work that does something.  With this in mind, students take a lot of time to research their topics and compose their projects in ways that communicate the highest expressions of their ideas.  They produce works that do something.  Though Shipka’s students do not typically write the classic research essay “print-linear alphabetic texts,” they do write.  They write on shirts, shoes; they create dioramas on which they write. 

(decode this)
To those that are still dubious of Shipka’s methods, that believe that her students get off easy, that question the writing her students produce, Shipka, on pages 88-89, 102-103 and 115-116, explains the multistep process required of her students.  Writing from her own experiences with students and citing similar works, Shipka lets her readers and critics know that among other skills, her students extensively research using various means, come out being able to take risks, improve their reading and writing skills, gain a better understanding of the rhetorical process, are able to communicate to different audiences and learn different ways to write.  She also makes a case for the writing that they do produce by way of research notes, reflective writing and the writing that they produce on the surfaces of their various works.


“Still, I would argue that making the shift to these more open-ended, complexly mediated tasks is both worthwhile and necessary, especially at a time when many have underscored the importance of establishing an atmosphere where students are able to prove that, beyond being critically minded consumers of existing knowledge, they are also extremely capable, critically minded producers of new knowledge.” (104)
This quotes reminds of last semester’s readings which called for students, or young people, moving from the role of consumers to producers.  A point not touched on by Shipka is how these assignments potentially affect students from low socioeconomic communities.  I imagine that many are accustomed to simply sitting in a classroom and receiving information, or not receiving information.  Having been one such student, I understand the lack of self-confidence that these students sometimes feel.  With some prodding, using Shipka’s methods of instruction, these students will be encouraged to see themselves as capable and as they learn that they are able to produce work that matters.

An assignment that I have done that somewhat resembles those of Shipka’s students was in my Education courses in college.  We had to create an e-portfolio.  Although there was a lot of traditional writing involved, such as essays and reflections, when it was initially assigned, our e-portfolios had to be representations of who we are.  As such, the pictures, videos, colors and designs that we chose had to communicate thoughful messages.  At first, the assignment fulfilled some of the points explained by Shipka such as “collecting data from texts…searching online...recording…conducting surveys…interviews...” (88).   Overtime the e-portfolio assignment changed as this assignment spanned more than one semester and gradually, more stress was added.  This is to say that when instructors assign these types of works, they must be careful not to counter their original purposes which for me and my classmates included student autonomy and self-expression.  Still, no other assignment in college left me with as much introspection as the e-portfolio did.  It was all at once expository, argumentative, research-based and fun.  It was more work than the standard college essay.

1 comment:

  1. Iris

    I 100% agree with you, Shipka's students do not get off easy. In fact, as I read the research involved (especially in the Lost & Found example) I kept thinking to myself that the students were doing a lot of work; almost more than would normally be required for an intro-level course. So, at first, I was confused. I thought how could this, at all, be appealing to a math major, art major, etc (not a science major, they're one of a kind. they love to read, write and do experiements)? I guess the allure is that there is a compromise. If you allow me to give you a presentation in a way that's comfortable to me then I will feel better about explaining my process in a medium of your choosing. For the students, I assume, there is great value in that.

    Sarah

    Thank you for mentioning your e-portfolio assignment and how it relates to the various tasks assigned by Shipka. I initially found Shipka's assignments to be a bit off-putting and esoteric, but after reflecting on the arguments laid out in her book I more fully understand her purpose: she wants her students to understand and articulate their own goals and the processes by which they will work to reach those goals. The reflective process writing Shipka assigns--just like your e-portfolio--encourages her students to think about what they are really trying to say and how they can best say it. Shipka's methods may be different from those we are used to, but her goal of getting her students to use multimodal forms of composition to foster a comprehensive understanding of their own processes and effectively communicate this information is not so far-fetched.


    Peele


    As I have said elsewhere, I don’t think students get off easily at all, and I’m surprised that people to think this. It’s so much harder to do something whose form hasn’t been handed to you. This isn’t to say that I think conventional essays are easy to write just because that form is known, but I do agree with Shipka in that it seems that these essays are hard to take seriously. Essays like these often seem like an item on a checklist. I also agree with your point, citing Shipka, that producing knowledge makes you a much better consumer of knowledge. Once you’ve made a video, you understand the magic.

    In regard to socioeconomic status, one concern of mine has been that in not teaching conventional literacies we’re depriving students of tools they need to negotiate the market place. Someone could make the case that in not delivering information about conventional structure and not focusing on correctness we’re further marginalizing already marginalized students.

    I agree with your point about portfolios. Many have argued, and I agree, that much of the learning happens in the reflective letter.


    Vivian

    Thanks for describing the positive experience you had with the assignment in your education class. It sounds like the work you did on the eportfolio culminated in exactly the kind of comprehensive result that Shipka describes is the purpose of her assignments.

    Your sense that the lack of self-confidence often felt by students from low socioeconomic communities could possibly be overcome "with some prodding" using Shipka’s methods speaks for their strength as well.

    In response to Tom's comment about further marginalizing students by not teaching alloy conventional structures and correct forms, I agree with this point. But I feel that it is equally as marginalizing in this day and age to not deliver information about how to develop rhetorical flexibility as readers and writers in multiple modes of communication.
    There must be a way to do both.

    ReplyDelete